Silent Hunter Submarines Pacific Fleet logo
Sub Asiatic SoWesPac logo
Silent Hunter header

USS Sculpin (SS-191)

USS Sculpin (SS-191) patch


The USS Sculpin (SS-191) was a Sargo-class World War II era submarine.

The namesake of the USS Sculpin is a spiny, large-headed, broad-mouthed, usually scale-less fish of the family Cottidae. Several species are found on the Atlantic coasts of Europe and North America.

The radio call sign of the USS Sculpin was NAN-EASY-LOVE-SUGAR.

On November 5, 1943, the Sculpin departed Pearl Harbor for her ninth and final war patrol. She had been ordered to patrol north of the Japanese stronghold at Truk Atoll and to attack Japanese forces sortieing from Truk's northern passage during the Gilbert Islands campaign (Operation Galvanic). On November 7, 1943, she topped off her fuel tanks at Johnston Island, and then headed for her assigned patrol area with the Sculpin's new captain, Commander Fred Connaway, at the helm.

At the direction of Admiral Charles A. Lockwood, Captain John P. Cromwell was aboard the Sculpin to coordinate wolf pack operations, as necessary. If activated by Cromwell, the pack would consist of either the Sculpin and the USS Searaven (SS-196) or the Sculpin and the USS Apogon (SS-308). Cromwell possessed extensive knowledge of the Operation Galvanic plans and of the Ultra intelligence system. Lockwood had cautioned him not to disclose any information about Operation Galvanic to the Sculpin's crew to eliminate the possibility of it being extracted from them by the Japanese. 1

On November 19, 1943, while making a surface end-around run to attack a Japanese convoy, the Sculpin was detected by the IJN destroyer Yamagumo and fatally damaged by depth charges. Due to the heavy damages she was forced to surface and fight the Yamagumo with her deck guns. It was a one-sided engagement. The ensuing gun battle killed Commander Connaway, his executive officer, and the gunnery officer, and inflicted additional damage to the Sculpin. Command of the Sculpin passed to the remaining senior officer, who ordered the boat scuttled and abandoned. After most of the surviving crewmen had escaped, the Sculpin was deliberately flooded with Captain Cromwell and eleven other men still aboard, some dead and others there by choice. Cromwell chose to go down with the boat to prevent the enemy from obtaining the secret information he possessed. For this action, he was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor. 2

Forty-two of the Sculpin's crew members were picked up by the Yamagumo. One badly wounded sailor was thrown back in the sea by the Japanese. Two groups of crewmen were embarked on separate aircraft carriers returning to Japan. One group had twenty-one crewmen, and the other twenty. One of them, the escort carrier Chuyo, which was carrying the group with twenty-one crewmen, was sunk by the USS Sailfish (SS-192) and twenty of the American prisoners perished. The one survivor was able to grab hold of a ladder on the side of a passing Japanese destroyer and haul himself aboard it. He was eventually sent to the Ashio copper mines. On December 5, 1943, the other twenty survivors arrived at Ofuna, Japan and were also eventually detailed to the Ashio copper mines for the duration of the war. 3

On December 30, 1943, after the Sculpin failed to acknowledge several radio messages, she was listed as presumed lost. She was struck from the Navy list on March 25, 1944.

The Navy Department issued the following press release regarding the Sculpin's loss:

Navy Department Communiqué 510, March 18, 1944

1. The submarines USS Capelin and USS Sculpin are overdue from patrol and must be presumed to be lost.

2. The next of kin of personnel in the Capelin and the Sculpin have been so notified.

The Sculpin was awarded eight battle stars for her service in World War II, in addition to the Philippine Presidential Unit Citation. She was scored by JANAC for sinking 9,835 tons of Japanese shipping in three vessels. Her Alden-McDonald score is five vessels sunk worth 10,049 tons and three vessels damaged for 13,248 tons. Her SORG score is seven vessels sunk for 42,200 tons and ten vessels damaged for 63,000 tons. 4

A discussion of Sculpin would be incomplete without mentioning her unique relationship with her sister ship, USS Squalus (SS-192). On May 23, 1939, Squalus suffered a catastrophic valve failure during a test dive off the Isle of Shoals, in the Gulf of Maine. The submarine sank to the bottom and came to rest keel down in 243 feet of water. Sculpin spotted Squalus's telephone buoy, and shortly thereafter thirty-three surviving crew members were rescued by a McCann Rescue Chamber. Twenty-three men died in the flooding aboard Squalus. On September 13, 1939, Squalus was raised and towed to the Portsmouth Navy Yard. She was refurbished and renamed USS Sailfish on February 9, 1940. Many consider it a cruel twist of fate that Squalus re-born as Sailfish sank the IJN escort carrier Chuyo, and with its sinking caused twenty members of Sculpin's crew to begin their eternal patrols. 5

Twenty-one Sculpin crew members survived the sinking and imprisonment.

A list of the men lost with the Sculpin is maintained at http://www.oneternalpatrol.com/uss-sculpin-191.htm.



Patrol Data and Captains for the USS Sculpin (SS-191)


Patrol
No.
Patrol
Area
Patrol Duration
DD-MM-YY
Captain's
Rank & Name
Sailed
From
 
1 Off Northern
Luzon Island;
ended at Surabaya
08-Dec-41 to 22-Jan-42 LCDR Lucius H. Chappell Manila
⇒ Surabaya
 
2 Celebes Area:
ended at
Exmouth Gulf
30-Jan-42 to 28-Feb-42 Same Surabaya
⇒ Exmouth Gulf 6
 
3 Moluccas Area 13-Mar-42 to 27-Apr-42 Same Fremantle
 
4 South China
Sea
29-May-42 to 17-Jul-42 Same Fremantle;
shifted to Brisbane
before fifth patrol
 
5 Bismarck Sea 08-Sep-42 to 26-Oct-42 Same Brisbane
 
6 Off Truk in the
Caroline Islands;
ended at Pearl
for overhaul
18-Nov-42 to 08-Jan-43 Same Brisbane
⇒ Pearl
 
7 Off Honshu;
ended at Midway
24-May-43 to 04-Jul-43 Same Pearl
⇒ Midway
 
8 Formosa;
ended at Pearl
25-Jul-43 to 17-Sep-43 Same Midway
⇒ Pearl
 
9 North of Truk 05-Nov-43 to 19-Nov-43
Lost
CDR Fred Connaway Pearl
 


JANAC Score for the USS Sculpin (SS-191)


Patrol
No.
Date
DD-MM-YY
Vessel
Name
Vessel
Type
Tonnage
Sunk
Location
Sunk
 
5 07-Oct-42 Naminoue Maru Transport 4,731 3-51S, 151-21E
 
5 14-Oct-42 Sumiyoshi Maru Cargo 1,921 3-20S, 150-03E
 
8 09-Aug-43 Sekko Maru Cargo 3,183 24-51N, 122-12E
 
TOTALS   3 vessels 9,835 tons  
 


Alden-McDonald Score for the USS Sculpin (SS-191)


Patrol
No.
Date
DD-MM-YY
Vessel
Name
Vessel
Type
Tonnage
Sunk
Tonnage
Damaged
 
2 04-Feb-42 Suzukaze Destroyer   1,980
 
4 07-Jul-42 San Pedro Maru Tanker   7,268
 
5 07-Oct-42 Naminoue Maru Passenger-
Cargo
4,731  
 
5 14-Oct-42 Sumiyoshi Maru Cargo 1,921  
 
5 18-Oct-42 Unknown Cargo 4   4,000
 
7 19-Jun-43 Sagami Maru Picket Boat 135  
 
7 19-Jun-43 Miyasho Maru #1 Fishing Boat 79  
 
8 09-Aug-43 Sekko Maru Passenger-
Cargo
3,183  
 
  TOTALS 5 vessels sunk
3 vessels damaged
4 = Possible Tons sunk
10,049
Tons damaged
13,248
 


SORG Score for the USS Sculpin (SS-191)


SORG Score Report for the USS Sculpin (SS-191)

SORG totals for Sculpin
7 vessels sunk for 42,200 tons
10 vessels damaged for 63,000 tons




signature
Updated Saturday, 28-Sep-2013 16:55:54 EDT

divider

1. Moore, Stephen L., Presumed Lost: The Incredible Ordeal of America's Submarine POWs during the Pacific War, p. 124.

2. Blair, Clay Jr., Silent Victory: The U. S. Submarine War Against Japan, p. 525; ; Miller, Vernon J., "U. S. Submarine Losses," issue 44, p. 54.

3. Moore, op. cit., p. 151-156.

4. Alden, John D., and Craig R. McDonald, United States and Allied Submarine Successes in the Pacific and Far East During World War II, Fourth Edition, see USS Sculpin (SS-191), Attack Nos. 36, 56, 58, 106, 200, 201, 202, 205, 229, 338, 353, 364, 370, 473, 884, 895, 900, 914, and 1018; Submarine war patrol reports on CD, data collected by the Submarine Operations Research Group (SORG) in the report "Results of U. S. Submarine War Patrols Listed Alphabetically by Name of Submarine"; Japanese Naval And Merchant Shipping Losses During World War II By All Causes, Joint Army-Navy Assessment Committee, USS Sculpin (SS-191), published online at http://www.ibiblio.org/hyperwar/Japan/IJN/JANAC-Losses/JANAC-Losses-6.html#sculpin (accessed September 29, 2011).

5. Blair, op. cit., p. 67.

6. The Sculpin was damaged by enemy depth charges during her second patrol and had to return to Exmouth Gulf for repairs. She sailed to Fremantle before her third patrol.